极速赛车168官网 Comments on: Why Reality Includes More (Not Less) Than You May Think https://strangenotions.com/why-reality-includes-more-not-less-than-you-may-think/ A Digital Areopagus // Reason. Faith. Dialogue. Sat, 19 Aug 2023 19:24:00 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.1 极速赛车168官网 By: Ficino https://strangenotions.com/why-reality-includes-more-not-less-than-you-may-think/#comment-236919 Sat, 19 Aug 2023 19:24:00 +0000 http://strangenotions.com/?p=5539#comment-236919 In reply to Thomas.

Kreeft writes,

So the claim that we can know that there is no God logically implies that the person who makes that claim has omniscience, that is, is God.

This is not what reductionists claim, or at least, they need not (I would say, should not) claim to know that there is no God. Kreeft's "refutation of reductionism in general" is a case of strawmanning.

]]>
极速赛车168官网 By: Thomas https://strangenotions.com/why-reality-includes-more-not-less-than-you-may-think/#comment-236766 Thu, 17 Aug 2023 01:09:00 +0000 http://strangenotions.com/?p=5539#comment-236766 Can someone explain to me why reductionism is wrong. It makes perfect sense to me but Catholic philosophers across the board seem set against it.

]]>
极速赛车168官网 By: Doug Shaver https://strangenotions.com/why-reality-includes-more-not-less-than-you-may-think/#comment-130111 Sun, 07 Jun 2015 17:48:00 +0000 http://strangenotions.com/?p=5539#comment-130111 In reply to Lucretius.

I know some who clearly do such, actually.

That doesn't answer the question I asked.

]]>
极速赛车168官网 By: Doug Shaver https://strangenotions.com/why-reality-includes-more-not-less-than-you-may-think/#comment-130108 Sun, 07 Jun 2015 17:48:00 +0000 http://strangenotions.com/?p=5539#comment-130108 In reply to Lucretius.

The person who seriously denies the existence of the sun is either committed to a way of thinking that he refuses to abandon, even to the point of insanity, or he is mentally ill.

I didn't ask for an evaluation of people who deny the existence of the sun. I asked why no such people are known to exist.

]]>
极速赛车168官网 By: Lucretius https://strangenotions.com/why-reality-includes-more-not-less-than-you-may-think/#comment-130090 Sun, 07 Jun 2015 12:58:00 +0000 http://strangenotions.com/?p=5539#comment-130090 In reply to Doug Shaver.

I know some who clearly do such, actually.

Christi pax.

]]>
极速赛车168官网 By: Lucretius https://strangenotions.com/why-reality-includes-more-not-less-than-you-may-think/#comment-130087 Sun, 07 Jun 2015 12:57:00 +0000 http://strangenotions.com/?p=5539#comment-130087 In reply to Doug Shaver.

No. The person who seriously denies the existence of the sun is either committed to a way of thinking that he refuses to abandon, even to the point of insanity, or he is mentally ill.

Christi pax.

]]>
极速赛车168官网 By: Doug Shaver https://strangenotions.com/why-reality-includes-more-not-less-than-you-may-think/#comment-130075 Sun, 07 Jun 2015 07:27:00 +0000 http://strangenotions.com/?p=5539#comment-130075 In reply to Lucretius.

(how can I choose to be an atheist if I don't know what that is?)

But you do know. So could you be one just by wanting to be one?

]]>
极速赛车168官网 By: Doug Shaver https://strangenotions.com/why-reality-includes-more-not-less-than-you-may-think/#comment-130072 Sun, 07 Jun 2015 07:25:00 +0000 http://strangenotions.com/?p=5539#comment-130072 In reply to Lucretius.

the will can influence the mind to go so far as to ignore information in order to reject a conclusion

So, the only reason nobody denies the sun's existence is that nobody wants to deny it?

]]>
极速赛车168官网 By: Loreen Lee https://strangenotions.com/why-reality-includes-more-not-less-than-you-may-think/#comment-129934 Sat, 06 Jun 2015 14:52:00 +0000 http://strangenotions.com/?p=5539#comment-129934 Why does it seem like there is so much Jungian coincidence in my life. Just found this on New Advent. What I talked about in another comment: why I have dared to call both this and the Scientism posts, alternative forms of a kind of 'fundamentalism' -Ban with if you will. http://www.opednews.com/articles/Pope-Francis-Calls-Right-W-by-James-Quandy-America_America_Anti-gay_CHRISTIANS-CANNOT

]]>
极速赛车168官网 By: Doug Shaver https://strangenotions.com/why-reality-includes-more-not-less-than-you-may-think/#comment-129844 Sat, 06 Jun 2015 04:07:00 +0000 http://strangenotions.com/?p=5539#comment-129844 In reply to Lucretius.

No one can make me worship the Sun, unless worship is defined as going through the motions

Yes, they can make you go through the motions, and that was my point. Behavior can be compelled. Thinking cannot be compelled.

But nobody, sun worshiper or not, has ever denied the sun's existence, and that unanimity of belief is not the result of any compulsion.

Descartes did at the beginning of his Meditations.

It was a thought experiment. By definition, it didn't really happen. If your response is: But he said he really did it, then my counter is: I don't think he meant it literally, and if he did mean it literally, then I just don't believe him.

]]>